The beautiful circular stained glass window titled Garden of Gethsemane, behind the pulpit in the sanctuary, was given to Bethelview in 1987 in loving memory of John Benjamin Norris, Rebecca Wagner Norris and Myra Brown Norris by their children and grandchildren. The current sanctuary was built that same year with the first worship service held in mid-August, 1987, and a consecration service held on October 11, 1987.
In October, 2013, leaded opalescent stained glass windows were installed at Bethelview. The window scene titles are Blessing the Little Children, Nativity, Crucifixion, and Resurrection. At the opposite end of the church from the circular window is the arched window, which is done in complementary opalescent stained glass. These stained glass windows were given in loving memory of Wilburn and Ruby Burgin and Fred and Eva Poovey by their children, Will and Barbara Burgin. A dedication service was held on December 15, 2013.